A Miraculous Ending to a Terrible Accident

Dona Naylor, horse trailer accident, horse trailer, Libby Naylor, Heather Tryon, Bonny Bonnello, horse accident, horse trailering, horse miracle

Dona Naylor, horse trailer accident, horse trailer, Libby Naylor, Heather Tryon, Bonny Bonnello, horse accident, horse trailering, horse miracle

By Dona Naylor

At 7 a.m. on November 25, 2011, Libby Naylor, a Vancouver Island dressage trainer, and Heather Tryon were heading north from Errington, BC, trailering two horses to a Bonny Bonello clinic in Courtenay, BC. They were just ten minutes from home when disaster struck.

Without warning, Libby felt and heard a bang from behind and experienced a surreal moment when she saw a horse trailer without a tow vehicle passing her on the right side of the truck.

“Oh my God, Heather!” she exclaimed, “It’s somebody’s horse trailer!” Suddenly she realized it was her own trailer that had detached from her truck.

The trailer hit the side of the truck, sending Libby and Heather spinning as Heather desperately clung to Zoula, Libby’s beloved dog. Libby gripped the steering wheel in a hopeless effort to control the truck as it spun across the median, finally coming to rest in a south-facing position. Then, as Libby and Heather watched helplessly, the horse trailer spun around, slammed into the bank on the side of the highway, and bounced before slamming down again on its side. Libby and Heather leaped from the truck to see to the horses and found them tangled in metal. The two women were unable to determine the extent of the horses’ injuries, or extract them from the trailer. Just then, a man ran up to them saying, “I am really sorry! It’s all my fault; I only looked down for a second.”

That second was all it took.

Dona Naylor, horse trailer accident, horse trailer, Libby Naylor, Heather Tryon, Bonny Bonnello, horse accident, horse trailering, horse miracle

The trailer was completely totaled and lying on its side when emergency responders arrived at the scene of the accident. Photo courtesy of Libby Naylor

The Qualicum Beach Fire Department, whom Libby and Heather cannot praise enough, was the first to respond to the accident, followed by other emergency vehicles. Meanwhile, Heather called a neighbour to bring her horse trailer in the hope that she could get the horses home once they had been removed from Libby’s trailer. She also phoned a local vet who responded immediately.

Attending to the horses was no easy task. Guinness, Heather’s horse with whom Libby trains and competes, is an 18-year-old, 16.3 hand Hanoverian gelding weighing 1400 pounds. Ritzy is a five-year-old, 17.3 hand Canadian Sport Horse gelding weighing 1200 pounds.

When the firemen opened the trailer, Guinness was curled up in a ball moaning while Ritzy reached down with his nose to comfort him with sounds and gestures, an act that moved many bystanders to tears.

Dona Naylor, horse trailer accident, horse trailer, Libby Naylor, Heather Tryon, Bonny Bonnello, horse accident, horse trailering, horse miracle

Libby's truck sustained minor damage but was able to be repaired. Photo courtesy of Libby Naylor

With Libby and Heather’s guidance, it took one-and-a-half hours and careful cutting with the Jaws of Life to remove the metal entangled around Ritzy. Once free of the metal, the young horse struggled out of the trailer and actually leaped over the ditch on the side of the road in his eagerness to be free of the trailer.

The fireman now tried to bring Guinness out, but he would not stand up. This proved to be too much for Libby and Heather, who went over to the truck out of sight of the trailer, terrified that the horse would never stand again. The firemen slowly hauled the gelding out with ropes, but even once he was out of the trailer, he would not move. Eventually, he slowly began to uncurl and finally made it to his feet. Many tears flowed freely at this point.

Miraculously, both horses appeared to have escaped serious injury, although if bruising showed on horses, there is no doubt that the two would have been covered from head to toe. It was now time to get them off the highway and home to properly assess the damage. Heather’s neighbour had arrived with the trailer, and unbelievably, after all the two horses had endured, they walked right into the trailer.

Dona Naylor, horse trailer accident, horse trailer, Libby Naylor, Heather Tryon, Bonny Bonnello, horse accident, horse trailering, horse miracle

Libby credits her solid CM trailer with protecting the horses during the accident. Photo courtesy of Libby Naylor

It wasn’t until the horses were home and safe in their stalls that the magnitude of the accident began to hit Libby and Heather. Their greatest concern had been for the animals, but it was clear that both women had also suffered great trauma.

Back at the accident site, both the trailer and the other driver’s vehicle were totalled, while Libby’s truck had sustained minor damage but was repairable.

Examination of the trailer revealed hoofprints on every wall and the roof, indicating just how much the horses were tossed around inside.

Fortunately, Libby is extremely cautious when it comes to trailering, and always applies full-length wraps to her horses’ legs, a practice that the vet says may have saved their lives. Libby also credits her custom-built CM trailer with helping prevent more serious injury to the horses.

Dona Naylor, horse trailer accident, horse trailer, Libby Naylor, Heather Tryon, Bonny Bonnello, horse accident, horse trailering, horse miracle

Today Guinness is miraculously back to doing canter pirouettes with Libby. Photo: Dona Naylor

Libby and Heather are also grateful to the people who stopped to assist them and the horses, among them a nurse who was the first to happen upon the scene and remained until the horses had been loaded on the trailer to be taken home.

“The first responders were great but truly did not know what to do in this sort of situation, but they were willing to listen,” says Libby. After the accident, Heather went to the fire hall where the firemen indicated an interest in learning more about how to handle situations involving horses, even suggesting that they have an equine veterinarian come and speak to them.

Libby is also positive that her incredible mother, who had recently passed away just a month prior to the accident, was with her in spirit throughout the experience.

“For sure Mom was the one who saved us,” says Libby. “We were seconds from the French Creek Bridge. [If the accident had taken place on the bridge] the horse trailer would have just gone off there into the ravine, and I have no idea where we would have ended up. No, Mom was right there with me.”

With Libby, Heather, the horses, and Zoula the dog home and relatively unscathed physically given the severity of the accident, the long healing process began. Both horses had suffered multiple injuries and were depressed, hanging their painful heads, unwilling to try to move for days. This demonstrated the degree of trauma their heads and necks had endured. But Guinness and Ritzy received the best possible care; Libby and Heather were with them constantly, providing them with veterinary care, massage therapy, magnetic blankets, and love.

Both horses have made tremendous recoveries. Guinness is again ready to perform canter pirouettes, and Ritzy has resumed being a playful youngster.

Dona Naylor, horse trailer accident, horse trailer, Libby Naylor, Heather Tryon, Bonny Bonnello, horse accident, horse trailering, horse miracle

Ritzy has also made an amazing recovery, and is back in work with Libby. Photo: Dona Naylor

Libby and Heather are incredibly grateful for the emails, phone calls, visits, and offers of help, as well as thankful to the fire department, police, and all others who have contributed to the recoveries of Guinness and Ritzy.

Advice that Libby and Heather would like to give to those trailering their horses would first be to thoroughly bandage the horses’ legs. In the case of their accident, the bandages likely saved the horses’ lives. Other tips they would offer include trailering in leather halters that will break. “Both horses would have had far more head and neck trauma had their halters not broken,” says Libby. “Extra halters should be kept in the vehicle, as you may not be able to access the tack room.”

Main Article Photo: The trailer was completely totaled and lying on its side when emergency responders arrived at the scene of the accident.

This article originally appeared in the April 2012 issue of Canadian Horse Journal.

Comments

Glad everyone recovered, but i am unclear as to why the trailer became unhitched from the truck? Based on the appology I am guessing they got rear-ended or something.

I'm glad this story had a happy ending, and it never ceases to amaze me how much trust our horses place in us.We had a similar accident, and our horses walked straight onto another truck to go home.

I am so happy to hear youall made it through ok! I am going to start wrapping legs when ever I travel with my horses. I already use leather halters, but not always wrap for short rides.

I hope every one makes a full recovery!

Image icon MarVee in Blue dress.jpg

Bright Blessings!

MarVeena Meek

It's truly a miracle all right! I wonder if the driver of the vehicle that rear ended them was on a cell phone or texting at the time?? I'm glad for the law that prohibits texting and hands-on phone usage. I've been hit twice by people not abiding this law!! Guiness must have amazing trust in Libby to be making the recovery that he has made so far. Cudos to Libby for her skills in all areas of horsemanship. I hope the women are getting trauma therapy themselves.

 

Image icon 2014-01-12 08.12.18.jpgImage icon 2014-01-12 08.08.14.jpgI recently had an accident too. We left on at 6:45 am and it was 42 degrees in Maine. The sky was blue and the roads were dry. We came to the highway entrance about 7:20 am at an area that was shaded and the sun had come up just enough to warm the road and the moisture came up on the road where the ground was still so cold it created black ice. I started to slide and was completely sideways across the lanes. I held the truck and trailer in line and as I thought I got it straight, the trailer continued to slide past me and hit the snow bank on the side of the highway. I heard the snap and it broke free from my truck and rolled. My daughter was following behind me as we were taking her horse back up to college with her after the winter break. Fortunately she was fine. I immediately kicked into gear and called a friend and told her I needed a trailer and the vet. I actually hadn't checked on the horse yet. My daughter couldn't imagine her horse was okay considering it was upside down. When we got to the trailer, he was on his side in the roof and was able to stand up in the roof. He could figure out he needed to stand on the one side as if he put weight on the other side it started to tip back. I was able to pry the ramp door open and some men who stopped had helped me hold it up and we backed him off the trailer. He came away with a few cuts and a sore neck and knee. He was wrapped and had a longer head tie than we usually use. We too learned we need an extra lead rope in the truck. He came out, stood on the side of the road eating some hay and drinking from his water bucket waiting for the other trailer. He got right back on. Two chiropractic visits and a massage and he was back to work in two weeks. I will never understand how blessed we were that day and feel the same that someone was up there watching over us. I thank God everyday for our good fortune. I think if we had just left even an hour later, the road would have cleared enough. My poor daughter had to continue on the remaining 4 hour drive back to school that day with her friend to get back for classes and said the roads were completely dry the rest of the way. It was just the "perfect storm" so to speak. I keep trying to figure out what I could have done differently. I have never felt so out of control of a situation. We trailer many miles for horse shows all over New England throughout the year. I now have one more thing I have learned about outside temperature vs. ground temperature and time of day creating unsafe conditions.

Image icon 2014-01-12 08.12.18.jpgImage icon 2014-01-12 08.08.14.jpgI recently had an accident too. We left on at 6:45 am and it was 42 degrees in Maine. The sky was blue and the roads were dry. We came to the highway entrance about 7:20 am at an area that was shaded and the sun had come up just enough to warm the road and the moisture came up on the road where the ground was still so cold it created black ice. I started to slide and was completely sideways across the lanes. I held the truck and trailer in line and as I thought I got it straight, the trailer continued to slide past me and hit the snow bank on the side of the highway. I heard the snap and it broke free from my truck and rolled. My daughter was following behind me as we were taking her horse back up to college with her after the winter break. Fortunately she was fine. I immediately kicked into gear and called a friend and told her I needed a trailer and the vet. I actually hadn't checked on the horse yet. My daughter couldn't imagine her horse was okay considering it was upside down. When we got to the trailer, he was on his side in the roof and was able to stand up in the roof. He could figure out he needed to stand on the one side as if he put weight on the other side it started to tip back. I was able to pry the ramp door open and some men who stopped had helped me hold it up and we backed him off the trailer. He came away with a few cuts and a sore neck and knee. He was wrapped and had a longer head tie than we usually use. We too learned we need an extra lead rope in the truck. He came out, stood on the side of the road eating some hay and drinking from his water bucket waiting for the other trailer. He got right back on. Two chiropractic visits and a massage and he was back to work in two weeks. I will never understand how blessed we were that day and feel the same that someone was up there watching over us. I thank God everyday for our good fortune. I think if we had just left even an hour later, the road would have cleared enough. My poor daughter had to continue on the remaining 4 hour drive back to school that day with her friend to get back for classes and said the roads were completely dry the rest of the way. It was just the "perfect storm" so to speak. I keep trying to figure out what I could have done differently. I have never felt so out of control of a situation. We trailer many miles for horse shows all over New England throughout the year. I now have one more thing I have learned about outside temperature vs. ground temperature and time of day creating unsafe conditions.

Log in or register to post comments
 

Advertisement

Related Articles

Advertisement

Advertisement

Help your favourite name advance - EQVALAN
 

Advertisement

RCMP Foundation 2018 Horse Auction

Advertisement

Olds College